10 Comments
User's avatar
Kurt's avatar

The Heritage Foundation used to publish a metric and list comparing the general intrusion of government into people's daily lives. They stopped publishing that "democracy list" in 2007 because China outscored the US as having less intrusion into citizens lives.

Marcus's avatar

For the china haters - if you have not been to china then dont comment. Go see the world through open eyes and ears - maybe then the world would be more tolerant. Oh and turn off the TV for starters.

Patrick Timbs's avatar

Interesting article. Agree with most of it. To me the greatest advantage of the Chinese system is that running the government/s is left to officials and the people are left to live their lives. The social contract means the people outsource the burden we in the West demand .In the West the vast majority of voters are ill equipped to vote and having done so they suffer the consequences and are often unhappy with the outcomes. And the politician’s abilities are very uneven and cyclical.

Nothing is perfect and there are always shortcomings. However I believe there is such a thing as too much freedom and democracy. Give me a Singapore or China every time.

HelenYang's avatar

Chinese culture value working hard would be reward, that’s their belief. Also, they value stability so many of them would put all their money for their home and kids. They could sacrifice themselves for their families. American culture value freedom and creativity, so they would not obey the social standard most of them would not want to do that. However, 14 billions ppl obey their government is more dangerous than to have different voices could be heard fr their government. Even if oligarch does not want to listen is like sometimes creativity is also a bad thing when comes fr Ai Chatbot.

Bill's avatar

The 2007 Index of Economic Freedom produced by the anti-China Heritage Foundation ranked China’s people as more free than Americans in the category “Freedom From Government “ see copies of relevant pages…

https://substack.com/@bill575555/note/c-169597210?r=50tspg&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=notes-share-action

Steve's avatar

For the maintenance of control over populations within The Empire, it is essential that the reality of life in China is kept firmly out of sight. It doesn’t take much imagination to know what would follow, if western peoples were aware of how the Chinese people live, and how their government serves them. Back in the 1970s, Soviet authorities were reluctant to allow citizens to travel abroad, for fear they would become infected with the western virus of freedom. I would imagine that today, both Chinese and Russian authorities welcome their citizens travelling to the west, since they are highly likely to come back inoculated against western ‘freedoms’.

MNT's avatar

I've heard this from others too😊

User's avatar
Comment removed
Sep 22, 2025
Comment removed
Cyrus Janssen's avatar

This is the problem with social media...you see one video of a rural village where this happened and people want to portray it as an entire nationwide policy that happened to millions of people. Give me a break, we can just use common sense and all agree the decision to weld someone in your apartment was stupid and wrong. It was also one case, and immediately was corrected. Let's just be more objective and rational in our analysis.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Sep 23, 2025
Comment removed
Cyrus Janssen's avatar

The fact that you said they have a social credit score is all I need to know. It means you've never spent a day in China. It doesn't exist, ask ANY Chinese person about this and they will tell you it's a complete lie. Sorry you've been lied to about China and believed the propaganda. You honestly should go visit and see for yourself

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 22, 2025
Comment deleted